Reesers Soft Ice Cream | A Sweet Retreat in Lewisberry, PA

Overview

Reesers' Soft Ice Cream, nestled at 880 Old Rossville Rd in Lewisberry, PA, offers a classic yet vibrant ice cream experience that draws locals and visitors alike. This family-run ice cream shop has built a reputation on its rich variety of soft-serve flavors and nostalgic sundae creations. From the creamy Peanut Butter and Pumpkin Cheesecake to the fresh, fruity Peach Sundaes and Blueberry Cobbler, each flavor rings true with natural, subtle sweetness that steers clear of artificial aftertastes.

The shop’s atmosphere complements its menu. With a spacious parking lot and outdoor picnic tables set up family-style, Reesers invites casual gatherings and simple pleasures. The small grassy seating area adds a touch of comfort for those wanting to linger and enjoy their treats slowly. Though the burger and sandwich options offer a typical American drive-in fare, they serve as a hearty complement rather than the main attraction.

Customer experience here is shaped by friendly, efficient staff who keep the line moving swiftly despite its popularity, a testament to both quality and demand. The mix of fast service and wholesome food creates a welcoming environment ideal for families, friends, and anyone seeking a sweet escape. The presence of mini golf beside the shop also means it’s more than just a quick stop — it’s a place for moments and memories.

Reesers stands out not just because of its generous, well-portioned servings, but because it honors a simple principle: quality ice cream enjoyed in good company, in a relaxed setting. Whether you're a fan of classic birthday cake ice cream, intrigued by a Samoa sundae, or curious to try the Walnut Cinnamon blend, this spot is proof that an unpretentious ice cream joint can make a lasting impression. For anyone traveling through or living near Lewisberry, Reesers’ Soft Ice Cream offers a satisfying treat well worth the visit.

Menu Highlights

See Full Menu

Amenities & Services

Popular for

Solo dining

Offerings

Coffee

Atmosphere

Casual

Trending

What Customers Say

Brandon P

Dec 3,2025

4/5

We came here for the ice cream only. But they do offer basic sandwiches, burgers and typical carryout dinner/lunch affairs to choose from. As far as the selection of ice cream flavors and types, wow. They have a lot of things to choose from. The oach Sunday was delicious and my son's reseed Sunday was delicious and the portion sizes are good enough that a small was plenty. They had a line sitting out but it moved fairly fast. The people working behind the counter were pleasant and we would come here again if we were in the area.

Syd-Centered

Dec 3,2025

5/5

Truly the best soft-serve ice cream and excellent french fries! I recently tried another place because the line was so long at Reeser's, and Reeser's was both cheaper and tasted better. Reeser's is worth the wait.

maj21093

Dec 3,2025

5/5

Reesers is a long-time family favorite, and even though we live 25 minutes away, it's totally worth the drive to get there. The flavors are subtle, without tasting artificial. The Pumpkin and Peanut Butter are my two favorites, with Strawberry being a close 3rd. The food, typical of most American "drive-in" establishments, is nothing special, but definitely well-prepared and let's face it, not the reason anyone comes here, so try it yourself and do your own review. ;) The parking lot is huge, and the long to order is usually long, but it's definitely worth the wait. Staff is always friendly and fast. Prices are EXCELLENT!!

Morgan E

Dec 3,2025

5/5

Wholesome good place to get ice cream and food. Everything is always good. Plus, I'd Rather give my money to locals than to the corps...mini golf is fun too w my girls....good laughs, good times...good memories

Mika

Dec 3,2025

5/5

I ordered the Coffee and Vanilla mixed soft ice cream and the Hollywood burger. Ice cream was very good and burger was good. Service was insanely fast. Cashier polite. Prices are extremely cheap. Three picnic tables set up family style and small amount of seating in grass on chairs. I would come back again.

Christopher Horne

Dec 3,2025

5/5

Excellent little ice cream place! Our desserts were ready very quickly, were generously sized, and reasonably priced. If we are back in this area again, we will definitely stop in.

T Stoey

Dec 3,2025

5/5

Reeser's is the best! Have been coming here for years and will keep coming back. Some of the best ice cream in the area. It's absolutely worth the drive out! Great service and plenty of space for kids to run around. The food AND ice cream menu is huge here! They have specialty flavors different weeks throughout the year, so check the schedule. Highly recommend the Artic Swirl - you can customize it and fill it with whatever you like! Note: The line does get very long, especially after dinner hours, but it's worth the wait and usually goes down fast.